If you’re shopping for a Tesla in Utah, you’ve probably narrowed it down to the Model 3 or the Model Y.

It’s a popular comparison, especially now with the refreshed Model 3 Highland and the buzz around the upcoming Model Y Juniper. Whether you're driving through the Wasatch Front, heading up to the mountains, or just navigating your Salt Lake City commute, choosing the right Tesla comes down to how you live, drive, and explore in Utah’s unique landscape

Let’s kick things off with a quick overview of both electric cars.

Quick Overview: Tesla Model 3 and Model Y at a Glance

At first glance, the Tesla Model 3 and Tesla Model Y seem like close siblings—and that’s because they are. They share the same platform, many of the same components, and a nearly identical tech experience inside. But their form factors make a big difference in how each one feels to drive and live with.

The Model 3 is Tesla’s compact electric sedan. It’s sleek, lower to the ground, and built for efficiency and sporty handling. This is the car that helped bring Tesla to the mainstream, and it’s often seen as the more “driver-focused” option.

The Model Y, on the other hand, is Tesla’s compact crossover SUV. It’s slightly taller, roomier, and designed with more versatility in mind. It’s based on the same platform as the Model 3, but it adds extra cargo space, a higher seating position, and even the option for a third row (in some trims).

In short:

  • Model 3 = low, sleek, and sporty
  • Model Y = taller, roomier, and more practical

Performance and Driving Experience

Tesla’s known for performance, and both the Model 3 and Model Y deliver—just in slightly different ways.

If you’re after a more athletic, responsive drive, the Model 3 has the edge. It’s lower to the ground, more aerodynamic, and just feels more planted when you take a curve or accelerate hard. Even the base Model 3 is quick, going from 0–60 mph in about 5.8 seconds. Step up to the Performance trim, and you’re looking at a 0–60 time under 3.2 seconds.

The Model Y is no slouch either, but it’s tuned a bit differently. It rides higher like an SUV, and while that adds practicality, it also changes the feel—less sharp in corners, but more commanding on the road. It’s still fast though: the Performance Model Y hits 0–60 in just 3.5 seconds, which is wild for a crossover.

Both vehicles offer:

  • Rear-wheel or all-wheel drive options, depending on trim
  • Instant electric torque and smooth single-speed acceleration
  • Regenerative braking for a one-pedal driving feel

If you love feeling connected to the road, the Model 3 is more fun to drive. If you prioritize comfort, visibility, and a slightly more relaxed experience, the Model Y might win you over.

Interior and Cargo Space

Here’s where the Model Y starts to pull ahead—literally, in terms of space.

Both vehicles share Tesla’s signature minimalist interior: a clean dash, a central touchscreen, and no instrument cluster behind the steering wheel. You get the same software experience, same panoramic glass roof, and the same high-quality materials across trims. But the dimensions make a noticeable difference once you're inside.

Seating and Passenger Space

  • Model 3 seats 5 and feels cozy—great for solo drivers or couples.
  • Model Y seats 5 standard, with an optional 7-seat configuration (mostly for kids).
  • The Model Y offers more headroom and legroom, especially in the back seat. Passengers sit higher, which many people find more comfortable for getting in and out.

Storage and Cargo Volume

This is where the Model Y really shines:

  • Model 3 has 23 cubic feet of total cargo space.
  • Model Y more than doubles that with about 76 cubic feet (with seats folded).
  • The Model Y’s hatchback design also makes loading large items way easier.

So if you’re regularly hauling gear, groceries, luggage—or kids—the Model Y gives you a lot more flexibility. If you value a tighter, more sedan-like space, the Model 3 is sleek and efficient.

Range and Charging

Range anxiety? Tesla's got that mostly covered—both the Model 3 and Model Y offer impressive range, but there are some key differences depending on the trim you choose.

Range by Trim (EPA Estimates)

On paper, the Model 3 Long Range wins for maximum range, largely because it’s lighter and more aerodynamic. That said, real-world conditions—like driving style, climate, and terrain—can bring the numbers a bit closer together.

Charging

Both models come with:

  • Access to Tesla’s Supercharger network, which is fast and widespread
  • Home charging compatibility with Tesla’s Wall Connector or a standard 240V outlet
  • Estimated 15–30 minutes to get ~200 miles on a Supercharger

There’s no meaningful difference in charging speed or technology between the two. You’ll have the same plug, same app, and same network—whether you’re zipping across town or road-tripping across states.

Bottom line: If every mile of range counts, go for the Model 3 Long Range. If you’re okay with slightly less but want more space, the Model Y Long Range is still a top performer.

Technology and Features

Tesla doesn’t do traditional trim levels the way other automakers do, but both the Model 3 and Model Y pack in a ton of tech, even at the base level.

Infotainment and Interior Tech

Both models come with:

  • A 15-inch central touchscreen that controls almost everything
  • Built-in navigation with live traffic and Supercharger routing
  • Streaming services like Spotify, Netflix, and YouTube (when parked)
  • Voice controls, Bluetooth, and over-the-air software updates

The experience inside is nearly identical. In a Model 3 or a Model Y. You're getting the same minimalist interface, same software features, and same speed when tapping through menus.

Driver Assistance and Autopilot

Every Model 3 and Model Y comes standard with Autopilot, which includes:

  • Adaptive cruise control
  • Lane keeping
  • Emergency braking

For an extra cost, you can upgrade to:

  • Enhanced Autopilot (adds Navigate on Autopilot, Auto Lane Change, and Smart Summon)
  • Full Self-Driving (FSD) (adds traffic light and stop sign control, and city street navigation in beta)

Hardware-wise, the two cars are virtually the same. They share Tesla’s latest sensor suite and computing platform. Any future software updates—especially to FSD—will roll out to both models at the same time.

In short: If tech is a deciding factor, you won’t miss out with either model.

Price and Value

Here’s where things get real: the price tag. While both vehicles offer strong value for what they deliver, there’s a noticeable cost difference between the Model 3 and Model Y—especially once you start climbing the trim ladder.

Base Price (Before Incentives)

  • Model 3 RWD: Starts around $38,990
  • Model 3 Long Range: About $47,740
  • Model 3 Performance: Roughly $54,630
  • Model Y Long Range: Starts around $52,990
  • Model Y Performance: Around $56,990

What You Get for the Price

You’re paying more for the Model Y’s added space, hatchback design, and SUV versatility. If those aren’t must-haves for you, the Model 3 offers similar performance, range, and features for several thousand dollars less.

That said, resale value on Teslas tends to be strong across the board, and many buyers recoup a good chunk of their investment. Plus, both vehicles may qualify for federal and state EV tax credits, depending on where you live and your income level.

Also worth noting: with fewer moving parts than gas-powered cars, Tesla maintenance costs are lower over time—though insurance premiums can be higher, especially for the Performance trims.

Bang for Your Buck

  • Budget-conscious drivers: Model 3 is your better bet
  • Families or flexibility-seekers: Model Y gives more for the extra money
  • Performance-minded buyers: Both Performance models are neck-and-neck, so go with your preferred body style

Model 3 vs Model Y: The Bottom Line

Choosing between the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y ultimately comes down to what you value most in your day-to-day driving.

If you're still on the fence, the next best step is to test drive both models back-to-back—or better yet, read real-world reviews from owners who’ve made the same choice you’re facing now.

Want hands-on experience? Stop by Axio EV in Sandy, Utah. We’d love to help you find the best electric vehicle in Utah.

Categories: New Inventory, Pre-Owned Inventory

Search Blog

Subscribe to Our Blog